nothing says i love you more than

heart shaped meat

valentine’s day at lgcm

This Valentine’s Day, celebrate the love you share with your special someone by enjoying a home made meal with meat and seafood from Lake Geneva Country Meats! Avoid the stress of trying to find a reservation, and make your favorite dish in the comfort of your own home. To help you celebrate, we’re bringing back our popular Surf & Turf special, plus offering a few special items. Check it out:

  • Surf & Turf special – save $3 on any lobster tail purchased with any 6 oz. or larger steak!
  • Dry Aged Rib Steaks will be available starting February 8th for you to enjoy – and yes, these work with the Surf & Turf deal!
  • Heart Shaped Rib Steaks – nothing says “I love you” like splitting a heart shaped piece of meat. We’ll custom cut one of these just for you!
  • Gourmet burgers – for a more casual meal, enjoy our famous 8 oz. brisket / chuck / sirloin / tenderloin blend, fresh starting on Friday, February 8th.

Keep reading to see what our most popular Valentine’s Day steaks, get recipe ideas, and place your order online.

Happy Valentine’s Day from Lake Geneva Country Meats!

grilled lobster tail and T bone steak surf and turf

our most popular steaks for valentine’s day

tenderloin filets

Tenderloin filets are the most tender cut of beef, with a buttery smooth flavor. Each filet is a perfect serving size for one person, and pairs perfectly with a lobster tail for Surf and Turf. 

• Our most popular filet size is cut at about 1-1.5″ and weighs 8 oz. per filet. We can cut a thicker filet for you, if desired!

• Filets cost $29.99/lb. or about $15 per 8 oz. filet. Center cut filets cost an additional $1 per lb.

Get our Tenderloin Filet cooking instructions here!

ribeye steaks

Ribeye steaks are our most flavorful and well marbled cut of beef. If you enjoy prime rib, you’ll love this steak. Try cooking these with mushrooms for a savory, indulgent meal!

• We generally cut Ribeye steaks at 1″ thick, and those steaks weigh about a pound each. We can cut them thicker or thinner if you like!

• Ribeyes cost $19.99/lb. or about $20 per 1″ thick steak.

Get our Ribeye sSteak with Balsamic Mushroom Sauce recipe here!

new york strip steaks

New York Strip Steaks are both flavorful and tender, and are less expensive than a filet or ribeye. They’re also a certified lean cut of beef! Try them with a compound butter on top for a burst of flavor.

• We generally cut New York Strip steaks at 1″ thick, and those steaks weigh about 12 oz. each. We can cut thicker or thinner if you like!

• Strip steaks cost $19.99/lb. or about $10.50 per 12 oz. steak.

Get our Strip Steak with Red Wine Compound Butter recipe here!

Dry age rib steaks

If you love rich, complex beef flavor, our Dry Aged Rib Steaks are for you! These bone-in steaks will be aged for 21+ days in our coolers to impart a distinctively rich flavor and tenderness to the meat. Some people describe the flavor as nutty, others as buttery, and others pick up savory, mushroom-y notes, but however you describe it, the flavor is unforgettable.

We will have a limited number of steaks available starting Friday, February 8th. We cut steaks at 1″ thick, unless specially requested thicker, and each steak weighs around 1.25#. We are offering them for $17.99/lb. or approximately $22.50 per steak. Reserve soon to ensure you get a steak!

nothing says i love you like heart shaped meat

Can we interest you in a steak for two?

If you’re a LGCM customer, you probably love great food, so why not celebrate your love on Valentine’s Day by splitting a Beef Rib Steak that’s cut in the shape of a heart? Our butchers will cut a beef rib into a heart shape for you to pan fry, grill, or broil and enjoy at home. Each steak weighs around 2 pounds, so these are definitely steaks to share! They cost $18.99/lb. – or around $38 per steak. Add twice baked potatoes, asparagus, and a bottle of wine for a meal to remember!

check out how easy it is to add a lobster tail to your meal!

cold water lobster tails at lgcm

At Lake Geneva Country Meats, we only buy cold water lobster tails for our store. Cold water lobster tails have a “cleaner” taste compared to a warm water tail that we think you’ll appreciate. We offer two sizes of lobster tails:

  • 4-5 oz. lobster tails – $8.99 each or $5.99 after Surf & Turf Discount.
  • 7-8 oz. lobster tails – $18.99 each of $15.99 after Surf & Turf Discount.

The 4-5 oz size. are very popular to enjoy with a steak, and for just $5.99, it won’t break the bank to enjoy lobster with your beef. Lobster tails are very easy to bake at home. You can watch our recipe video on this page, or just click the button below to see the full recipe!

Get our Baked Lobster Tail recipe here!

send us your Valentine’s order online!

Fill out this form with what you’d like for Valentine’s Day, and we’ll get it written up for you. Don’t worry if you don’t know exactly what you want, we’ll follow up to your order with an email to confirm all the details.

  • Please include how many of each steak you would like, and an approximate thickness or weight for each steak.
  • Please let us know how many tails you would like, and if you would like 4 oz., 8 oz., or both sizes of tails.
  • More meat? Twice Baked Potatoes? Chocolate? Wine? Let us know!

Have questions? Call us now at 262-248-3339 option 3 to order, or get your questions answered!