make your holiday better with

Fresh Thanksgiving Turkeys

Order Your Turkey Online Now

here are our turkey tips

#1 – Bigger isn’t necessarily better!

Turkeys take significantly longer to cook once they start going over 18 pounds. Larger birds are also hard to fit in ovens, so we recommend sticking with turkeys between 12 – 18 pounds.

#2 – Cook a party bird!

Instead of doing 1 larger turkey, try doing 2 smaller turkeys, or a turkey and a chicken. You can make a second turkey or chicken with a fun seasoning. Give it a try!

#3 – Order enough for everyone!

We recommend ordering 1 – 1.5# of meat per person you are serving. Thanksgiving is a holiday where people love to eat – and love leftovers – so don’t get caught short on quantity.

Order Your Turkey Now With Our Online Form!

Try One of these turkey recipes

roast turkey recipe

made with side pork!

  • Creates juicy and flavorful turkey.
  • Uses side pork (uncured / smoked bacon) to insulate the breast meat.
  • Works with any size turkey.

Get the full recipe here!

spatchcocked turkey recipe

say that three times fast!

  • This is the fastest way to cook a turkey.
  • The flattened turkey cooks evenly – we can even spatchcock it for you.
  • Works best with turkeys around 12 pounds.

Get the full recipe here!

smoked turkey recipe

get outside with your turkey!

  • Creates a super flavorful turkey.
  • Uses a lemon – butter – garlic injection for more flavor.
  • Works best with turkeys around 12 pounds.

Get the full recipe here!

add a thanksgiving Csa box

Add locally grown vegetables to your turkey order with one of our Thanksgiving CSA Boxes from The Farmstead! We have limited quantities of each box available, and they’re packed full of fresh, locally grown vegetables. Check out the boxes, and then order online by clicking the button below!

csa box #1

this box contains:

  • 1 Butternut Squash
  • 1 Pie Pumpkin
  • 3# of Yellow Onions
  • 5# of Yukon Gold Potatoes


csa box #2

this box contains:

  • 1 Acorn Squash + 1 Hearts of Gold Squash
  • 1 Pie Pumpkin
  • 3# of Yellow Onions
  • 5# of Yukon Gold Potatoes


about our turkeys

Turkeys on range

We are proud to offer fresh Amish Turkeys for you to enjoy this Thanksgiving. Our turkeys are raised on free range Amish farms in Ohio on vegetarian diets, free of anti-biotics. After they’re processed, our turkeys are rinsed clean and flash chilled to keep them fresh on their way to our store. There’s no added solution, no artificial seasoning, just delicious, natural turkey for your Thanksgiving table. Our turkeys cost $2.49/lb., and come in the following size ranges:

• 8 – 11 lbs.     • 12 – 15 lbs.     • 16 – 19 lbs.     • 20 – 23 lbs.     • 24 – 27 lbs.     • 28- 30 lbs.

Order Your Turkey Now With Our Online Form!

birds of a different feather

Save yourself time and aggravation by ordering a 12 – 18# turkey instead of a larger turkey! Fill in extra meat with a roast chicken or two. Try one of these fun, and easy to make roast chicken recipes from your favorite world cuisine. We recommend spatchcocking your chicken for the best results and fastest cooking.

cajun chicken

Add a bit of Cajun heat to your Thanksgiving with this recipe!

Get the full recipe here.

garam masala chicken

Bring the flavors of India to your table with this recipe!

Get the full recipe here.

Herbes de Provence Roasted Chicken

Herbes de Provence Roast Chicken

Enjoy Thanksgiving like you’re in the sunny, warm, South of France!

Get the full recipe here.

Za’atar Roast Chicken

Za'atar Roast Chicken

Bring fresh Mediterranean flavors to your Thanksgiving table!

Get the full recipe here.

feasts of a different beast

Add a little bit of variety to your meal with one of these recipes made from duck, goose, pork, or beef. These easy to make recipes can be enjoyed with a turkey, or if you’re sick of the turkey, in place of the turkey!

Roast Duck

Ducks are richly flavored birds full of dark meat. They’re wonderful to enjoy with cranberry sauce!

Get the full recipe.

roast goose

Geese are a traditional favorite for Christmas, but these birds are a great way to bring variety to your Thanksgiving.

Get the full recipe here.

cranberry apple stuffed pork loin

This stuffed pork loin uses some of fall’s best produce and can be used as a main dish or a supplement!

Get the full recipe here.


Beef. It’s what’s for Thanksgiving with this Autumn inspired roast, complete with delicious onion & pear rice!

Get the full recipe here.

Want a juicy turkey? Try brining it with these recipes!

Thanks for checking out our Thanksgiving page – are you ready to…